Sell faster
$520
Twenty percent below the current market median.
Based on 2 comparable used listings across 2 states listed over the past month, a used Ithaca Model 51 asks around $650. The cheapest current ones ask $650 in Milwaukee, WI and 1 more.
Used market snapshot
$650
The median asked price after customized, collectible, and unusually priced pre-owned listings are removed. Accessory-heavy listings are also excluded when enough comparable data remains.
Limited data: based on only 2 comparable listings, so treat this as a rough estimate.
Included asked-price range
Too few comparable pre-owned listings to show a range yet.
Suggested asking price
Balanced uses the filtered market median. The faster and patient options adjust that same price by fixed percentages.
$520
Twenty percent below the current market median.
$650
The current average asked price shown above.
$815
Twenty-five percent above the current market median.
Ready to sell your Ithaca Model 51?
Create your listing and choose the asking price that fits your timeline.
Cheapest current listings
Lowest comparable pre-owned asking prices currently included in this report.
Semi-Auto Shotguns
$650
Milwaukee, WI
Nov 15
Shotguns
$650
Austin, TX
Nov 18
Never miss a great price
Subscribe to new-listing notifications and we’ll let you know as soon as a matching Ithaca Model 51 appears near your chosen location.
Comparable pre-owned Ithaca Model 51 asking prices. States with the most listings are shown first.
Loading map...
All other current marketplace listings linked to this model.
Semi-Auto Shotguns
$200
Omaha, NE
9 hours ago
Ithaca Gun Company is an American maker best known for the Model 37 pump shotgun, which also built M1911 pistols in World War II.
The average asked price for a used Ithaca Model 51 is $650. It is the median of 2 comparable current pre-owned listings, left after customized, collectible, trade-only, accessory-heavy, and unusually priced listings are filtered out. With this few listings, treat it as a rough estimate. Pricing data was last updated in November 2026.
Based on the filtered used Ithaca Model 51 median, consider $520 to attract buyers faster, $650 for a balanced asking price, or $815 if you are willing to wait. These options are 20% below, equal to, and 25% above the filtered market median.
GunList analyzes marketplace listings explicitly linked to the Ithaca Model 51. It uses up to 300 of the most recently listed current listings. Listings priced under $50, customized, collectible, and trade-only listings are excluded. Accessory-heavy bundles are removed when enough comparable listings remain, then unusually low and high prices are filtered. The reported used value is the median asking price, not a completed-sale price or formal appraisal.
Ithaca Model 51 data for Texas shows an average asking price of $650. More state comparisons will appear as additional priced listings become available.
A Ithaca Model 51's value can change with condition, generation, finish, round count, factory configuration, modifications, included optics or magazines, original box and paperwork, provenance, and local demand. Customized or accessory-heavy examples may sell outside the comparable price range shown here.
Explore similar firearms
Other current models from the same firearm category.